Best Wired Doorbell Replacement: 2025 Expert Review
Oli at OR Electrics
Fully Qualified 18th Edition Electrician
It might seem like a small job, but a faulty doorbell is a genuine nuisance. I visit plenty of homes in Leeds where the doorbell hasn't worked since 1998 because the external button has corroded in the Yorkshire rain or the internal wiring has failed.
Whilst smart video doorbells are the current trend, there is still a massive demand for traditional wired doorbell replacements. Why? Because they don't rely on Wi-Fi, they don't need recharging every few weeks, and they are generally 'fit and forget' solutions.
In this review, I'm looking at three options for getting your doorbell ringing again: a budget replacement button, a premium illuminated metal button, and a classic internal chime unit for when the sounder itself has packed in.
Live in Leeds?
Doorbell wiring faulty?
Get a free quote for electrical repairs.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "Universal Compatibility"
"Marketing often claims buttons work with 'any' system."
This isn't always true. Illuminated buttons (with LEDs) require a constant current. If you have a battery-operated mechanical chime, the light might not work, or it might drain your batteries rapidly. Always check your power source (transformer vs batteries).
The Spec: "'Easy' Installation"
"Just two screws and you're done."
In places like Armley or Harehills with back-to-back terraces, wired doorbells often route through solid brick or behind ancient plaster. If the wires are short or brittle (common in 1970s wiring), a simple swap can turn into a fiddly rewiring job.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Door Bell Push Buttons, Universal Wired Door Bell Button
LAIXIABAO
This is your standard, no-nonsense replacement. If your old white plastic button has yellowed or cracked, this is the quickest, cheapest way to tidy up the front door. It handles the basics perfectly well without overcomplicating the wiring.
The Good
- Extremely affordable
- Slim profile fits narrow door frames common in Leeds terraces
- UV-resistant so it shouldn't yellow quickly in the sun
The Bad
- Non-illuminated (harder for deliveries to spot at night)
- Basic plastic feel won't suit premium properties
Installer Tip:
Because this unit is quite narrow (24mm), it's great for refreshing old buttons on uPVC door frames. However, if you are replacing a wide, square Victorian push, be prepared to do some filling and painting, as this won't cover the footprint of a larger old unit.
Priced at £4.56 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonRound Metal Doorbell Push Button, Wired Lighted Up LED
EasyByMall
If you want to upgrade the look of your entrance, this metal button is a solid step up from plastic. The LED ring is a practical addition for visitors arriving in the dark, and the metal construction offers far better protection against the accidental knocks common in busy households.
The Good
- Solid metal build feels much more durable than plastic
- LED light is very helpful for delivery drivers on dark winter evenings
- Waterproof design resists driving rain
The Bad
- Requires a compatible power source for the LED to function properly
- More expensive than standard plastic buttons
Installer Tip:
Before buying, check your transformer voltage. This LED button generally needs an 8V-12V transformer supply to light up continuously. If you just have batteries in the chime box inside, the light likely won't work, though the bell function might still operate.
Priced at £13.29 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonHoneywell Home Ding Dong Classic Wired Doorbell – White, D117
Honeywell Home
Sometimes the problem isn't the button outside, but the chime inside. Honeywell is the gold standard for these units. This is the classic 'ding-dong' sounder that is loud enough (80dB) for most family homes. It solves the issue of weak, buzzy, or broken internal units.
The Good
- Trusted Honeywell quality – these units last for decades
- Dual power options: can run on batteries if you don't have a mains transformer
- Loud 80dB volume ensures you hear the postman
The Bad
- Does not include the push button (this is the sounder only)
- Plastic casing is functional rather than stylish
Installer Tip:
I install loads of these in student HMOs in Headingley. I always recommend wiring them to a transformer (mains powered via the Consumer Unit) rather than using batteries. Tenants often 'borrow' batteries for other devices, leaving the doorbell dead—hard-wiring prevents this nuisance.
Priced at £11.04 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
My doorbell is buzzing but not ringing. What is the fault?
Is it safe to replace a wired doorbell myself?
Can I use an illuminated button with batteries?
Why has my wired doorbell stopped working?
Need Professional Emergency Electrical Services?
Our team at OR Electrics specialises in Emergency Electrical Services across Leeds.
Get a free quote for professional installation or fault finding.
View Our Emergency Electrical Services Service