Professional Guide

Best Smart Switches No Neutral for Older Homes: 2025 Expert Review

OR Electrics

18th Edition Qualified Electrician

Published 17 December 2025

One of the most common frustrations homeowners face when upgrading to smart lighting is discovering they have 'no neutral' at the switch. In the UK, specifically in older properties like the Victorian terraces common in Leeds, electricians traditionally used the 'loop-in at ceiling' method. This means the neutral wire stays in the ceiling rose, and only the live wire goes down to the switch.

Standard smart switches require a continuous power supply (Live and Neutral) to stay connected to your Wi-Fi or Zigbee network. Without a neutral, many standard smart switches simply won't work, or worse, they'll cause your lights to flicker or ghost (glow faintly when off).

Fortunately, technology has caught up. In this review, I'll walk you through three 'no neutral' solution I've installed or tested. We'll look at a battery-powered budget option, a premium Zigbee switch that's a favourite for stability, and a versatile choice for smart home enthusiasts.

Live in Leeds?

Confused by your wiring?

Get a free quote for professional smart switch installation.

Get a Quote

Specs vs. The Real World

The Spec: "Capacitor Requirements"

The Theory

"Manufacturers claim 'easy installation' without mentioning bypass capacitors."

The Reality

With 'no neutral' switches that harvest power from the live line, low-energy LED bulbs often flicker. You frequently need to install a capacitor (supplied) at the light fitting (ceiling rose) to stabilise the current, which requires getting the ladder out.

The Spec: "Hub Requirements"

The Theory

"Marketing often hides the need for a separate hub."

The Reality

Most reliable no-neutral switches use Zigbee, not Wi-Fi, because it uses less power. This means you ALMOST ALWAYS need the brand's specific hub (e.g., Tapo or Aqara) or a universal Zigbee dongle.

My Top 3 Recommendations

Three options to cover different needs and budgets

Tapo S210 Smart Light Switch 1 Gang 1 Way, No Neutral Needed

Budget Pick

Tapo

The Tapo S210 creates a clever workaround for the 'no neutral' problem by using batteries rather than harvesting power from the mains. This makes it safer for DIY enthusiasts as there's no risk of ghosting or flickering bulbs, but it does mean occasional battery changes.

Price£14.99 (at time of writing)

ConnectionRequires Tapo Hub (Sold Separately)

Power SourceBattery (Provided)

The Good

No complex wiring or capacitors needed
Battery power eliminates 'ghosting' issues with LEDs
Very affordable entry point

The Bad

Requires a Tapo Hub to function
Batteries will eventually need replacing (unlike wired options)

Installer Tip:

Because this switch effectively communicates wirelessly to the hub, it's a great solution if your backbox is extremely shallow (common in stone-built Leeds homes) where a deep wired smart switch wouldn't physically fit.

Priced at £14.99 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

Aqara Smart Wall Switch H1 (No Neutral, Double Rocker)

Quality Pick

Aqara

This is widely recognised as the gold standard for UK no-neutral smart switches. The build quality is exceptional, offering a tactile 'click' that feels like a premium traditional switch. It supports Apple HomeKit (via the hub) and fits seamlessly into standard UK backboxes.

Price£34.99 (at time of writing)

ProtocolZigbee 3.0

CompatibilityHomeKit, Alexa, Google (via Hub)

The Good

Excellent build quality and tactile feel
Supports Apple HomeKit (rare for no-neutral switches)
Decoupled mode allows it to control smart bulbs without cutting power

The Bad

More expensive than rivals
Requires Aqara Hub or Zigbee setup

Installer Tip:

If you use smart bulbs (like Philips Hue), this switch has a 'wireless switch mode'. This keeps the power to the bulb permanently on (so the bulb stays smart) whilst the switch button sends a signal to turn the light off via software. It stops family members from accidentally killing the power to your smart lights.

Priced at £34.99 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

SONOFF Orb-ZBW1L Zigbee 3.0 Smart Wall Switch

Problem-solving

SONOFF

For those running Home Assistant or Zigbee2MQTT setups, the SONOFF Orb is a fantastic problem solver. It's a wired solution (no batteries) that is optimised for low-wattage loads, reducing the likelihood of flicker even without a neutral wire. It's cost-effective and integrates well with non-proprietary hubs.

Price£14.84 (at time of writing)

LoadMin 3W, Max 6A

EcosystemZigbee 3.0 / Home Assistant Friendly

The Good

Works excellently with generic Zigbee dongles (ZHA/Zigbee2MQTT)
Optimised for low loads (3W) to reduce flicker
Very competitive price for a wired Zigbee switch

The Bad

Not compatible with smart bulbs (cuts power)
Industrial design is functional but less premium than Aqara

Installer Tip:

Whilst this claims to work without a neutral, if you are using very low wattage LEDs (under 5W total), you may still experience a slight flicker. In these cases, installing a bypass capacitor across the lamp holder (at the ceiling) is usually the fix. This requires working at height, so ensure you have safe access.

Priced at £14.84 at the time of writing

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I have a neutral wire at the switch?

Safely isolate the circuit at the consumer unit and unscrew the switch faceplate. If you see only two wires (usually Brown and Blue sleeve, or Red and Black) connected to 'COM' and 'L1', you likely have no neutral. A neutral wire is usually a bundle of blue/black wires terminated in a block at the back of the box, not connected to the switch itself. If in doubt, consult a qualified electrician.

Why do my lights flicker with a no-neutral switch?

No-neutral switches (except battery ones) must let a tiny amount of current trickle through the bulb to power their own Wi-Fi/Zigbee chip. Old incandescent bulbs didn't notice this, but modern LEDs are so efficient they might try to light up with this tiny current, causing a flash or flicker. A 'bypass capacitor' installed at the light fitting solves this by diverting the trickle current.

Are these switches safe for UK homes?

Yes, provided they are CE/UKCA marked and installed correctly. However, you must ensure your backbox is deep enough (usually 35mm+) to accommodate the bulkier electronics of a smart switch. In many Leeds Victorian terraces, backboxes are shallow, so you might need a spacer or a battery-powered option like the Tapo.

Do I need a hub for these switches?

Generally, yes. The Aqara and Tapo switches listed require their specific hubs (or a compatible Zigbee hub). This is actually a benefit; Zigbee uses less energy than Wi-Fi and creates a 'mesh' network, meaning your switches act as signal boosters for each other, which is helpful in houses with thick stone walls.

Can OR Electrics install these for me?

Absolutely. We specialise in smart home integrations. We can ensure the wiring is compliant, fit any necessary capacitors at the ceiling rose, and set up the hub for you to ensure everything works seamlessly.

What is the difference between Zigbee and Wi-Fi switches?

Wi-Fi switches connect directly to your router but consume more power and can congest your network. Zigbee switches connect to a central hub, use very little power (ideal for no-neutral setups), and work faster locally even if your internet goes down.

Need Professional Smart Home Lighting?

Our team at OR Electrics specialises in Smart Home Lighting across Leeds.

Get a free quote for professional installation/service.

View Our Smart Home Lighting Service