Best Retractive Light Switches for Smart Homes: 2025 Expert Review
Oli
Owner, OR Electrics
If you are upgrading your home with smart lighting modules like Shelly, Fibaro, or Sonoff, you quickly realise that standard rocker switches just don't feel right. You flick them 'on', then use the app to turn the light 'off', and suddenly your switch is in the wrong position. It's a small nuisance, but one that drives my customers mad.
The solution is a retractive switch (often called a momentary switch). These spring back to the off position immediately after you press them, sending a pulse to your smart dimmer or relay. It sounds simple, but finding high-quality retractive switches that don't feel cheap or get stuck can be a challenge, especially when trying to match existing décor.
In this review, I'm looking at three options I've installed in homes across Leeds. I've chosen a solid budget option, a premium finish for modern renovations, and a modular solution that helps solve tricky wiring configurations.
Live in Leeds?
Thinking about upgrading to smart lighting?
We can ensure your wiring is safe and compliant.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "Compatible with standard back boxes"
"Manufacturers fit standard 25mm or 35mm boxes."
Whilst the switch fits, once you add a smart puck (like a Shelly Dimmer) behind it, a 35mm box is often too tight. In the solid brick walls we see in Leeds, you almost always need a 47mm deep box for comfortable wiring.
The Spec: "Silent Operation"
"Retractive switches are quiet and smooth."
Most still have a distinct 'click'. Cheaper models can sound quite metallic. If the mechanism is stiff, it can feel like you are fighting the wall every time you turn the lights on.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
BG Electrical Single Retractive Bell Push Switch, Nexus Metal BS
British General
This is the trade secret for getting smart switching on a budget. Although technically labelled a 'Bell Push', it functions exactly as a retractive single-pole switch needed for smart relays. It's robust, affordable, and the brushed steel finish looks far more expensive than it is.
The Good
- Incredible value for money
- Moisture gasket included (great for newly plastered walls)
- Solid mechanical feel that returns reliably
The Bad
- Features a 'Bell' symbol on the button (aesthetic downside)
- Raised profile isn't as sleek as flat plate options
Installer Tip:
Use this for utility rooms or areas where function trumps form. The 'Bell' symbol puts some homeowners off using it in a lounge, but mechanically, it's brilliant for triggering smart relays without breaking the bank.
Priced at £3.42 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonSoho Lighting White Metal Flat Plate 2 Gang Retractive Light Switch
The Soho Lighting Company
For a high-end finish in a living room or kitchen, this Soho Lighting switch is top tier. It uses a grid system hidden behind a stunning screwless white metal plate. It's designed specifically for smart homes, so the action is smooth and reliable without any confusing symbols.
The Good
- Clean, screwless aesthetic looks fantastic in modern homes
- Modular grid system allows for easier maintenance
- Robust mechanism designed for frequent use
The Bad
- Significantly higher cost per unit
- Flat plate design requires perfectly flat walls
Installer Tip:
Flat plate switches are unforgiving on uneven walls. In many Leeds terraces, the plaster is rarely perfectly flat. You must ensure your back box is sunk slightly deeper than usual to allow the plate to pull flush against the wall without bowing.
Priced at £26.00 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonSoho Lighting White Metal Flat Plate 1 Gang Retractive Light Switch
The Soho Lighting Company
This is the single-gang version of the Soho range, but I've labelled it problem-solving because of its modular nature. Being a grid switch system provided separately means as an installer, I can swap modules or orientation if the room layout changes, whilst maintaining that high-end look.
The Good
- Modular assembly allows flexibility during installation
- High-quality construction reduces mechanism failure
- Matches the 2-gang version for consistent home styling
The Bad
- Assembly required (comes as separate parts)
- Requires deep back box for comfortable cabling
Installer Tip:
When fitting these grid switches, take care not to pinch the cables behind the yoke. Because it is a flat plate, there is zero void behind the front cover, so all your cable management must happen strictly inside the back box.
Priced at £19.00 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a retractive switch and a rocker switch?
Can I use a bell push as a light switch?
Do I need deeper back boxes for retractive smart switches?
Do these switches work with Philips Hue?
Why do you recommend metal switches in older houses?
Need Professional Smart Home Lighting?
Our team at OR Electrics specialises in Smart Home Lighting across Leeds.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Smart Home Lighting Service