Best Outdoor PIR Motion Sensors for Home Security: 2025 Expert Review
Oli at OR Electrics
18th Edition Fully Qualified Electrician
Winter in the UK means dark mornings and darker evenings. For homeowners, nothing is more frustrating than fumbling for keys in the pitch black or worrying about what's lurking in the garden. A reliable PIR (Passive Infrared) motion sensor is the first line of defence for home security.
However, not all sensors are created equal. As an electrician, I'm frequently called out to fix 'security lights' that have filled with rainwater, nuisance trip the RCD, or simply refuse to turn off. The damp climate here requires robust kit, and installing the wrong IP rating is a recipe for disaster.
In this review, I'm looking at three options currently on the market: a reliable standalone sensor for retrofitting, a modern integrated up/down light for contemporary homes, and a traditional lantern style that suits the aesthetic of our older brick properties.
Live in Leeds?
Need security lighting installed safely?
Get a free quote from our qualified team.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "IP Ratings (IP44 vs IP65)"
"Marketing materials often claim IP44 is perfectly fine for all outdoor use."
In my experience, IP44 is acceptable for sheltered areas (like a porch), but for exposed walls in Leeds facing driving rain, IP65 is far superior. IP44 units often succumb to water ingress over time if not positioned carefully.
The Spec: "Detection Range Claims"
"Sensors claim precise ranges like '12 metres' or '100% detection angle'."
Hedges, washing lines, and even spiders spinning webs across the lens can interfere with this. Sensitivity usually needs dialling down to avoid the light triggering every time a cat walks past or the wind blows a bush.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Luceco LGIP44WSB-01 LED Tilt and Swivel PIR Motion Sensor Wall Mounted Lighting
Luceco
This is a standalone sensor, meaning it doesn't produce light itself but switches other lights on. It's an excellent, cost-effective choice if you already have functioning floodlights but want to add automation, or if you want to control multiple lights from one sensor point. The IP65 rating is a massive plus for longevity.
The Good
- IP65 rated - highly resistant to Yorkshire rain
- Standalone unit allows you to control multiple existing lights
- Adjustable timer and lux (daylight) settings
The Bad
- Requires electrical knowledge to wire into existing circuits
- Aesthetic is purely functional/industrial
Installer Tip:
When mounting this, ensure the cable entry gland is pointing downwards and is tightened securely. Even with IP65, water can track down the cable and into the unit if you're not careful. Use a drip loop in the cable for extra safety.
Priced at £6.17 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonEXTRASTAR Smoky Grey Outdoor Wall Lights PIR Motion Sensor, GU10 Base Double Up Down
EXTRASTAR
For a sleek, modern look, this up/down light is a solid contender. It's popular for new builds or refurbishments, such as student lets in Hyde Park, where upgrading the kerb appeal is key. The die-cast aluminium body feels robust, and the GU10 lamp holders mean you can replace the bulbs rather than binning the whole unit when an LED fails.
The Good
- Replaceable GU10 bulbs (environmentally better than integrated LED)
- Modern design suits contemporary homes
- Durable die-cast aluminium body
The Bad
- IP44 rating - best installed under a soffit or porch
- Wiring space inside the backplate is tight
Installer Tip:
Use quality branded LED GU10 bulbs. Avoid old halogen bulbs in these fittings; the heat generated by halogens can cook the PIR sensor electronics over time, leading to failure. LEDs run cool and last longer.
Priced at £16.79 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonEXTRASTAR Outdoor 6 Sided Black Wall Lantern Security Light with PIR Motion Sensor
EXTRASTAR
I call this the 'problem solver' because it matches the aesthetic of Leeds' Victorian red-brick terraces perfectly. A modern steel cylinder often looks out of place on a 1900s house, whereas this lantern blends in. It integrates the PIR sensor into a classic design, giving you security without ruining the period look.
The Good
- Classic aesthetic fits older properties perfectly
- Uses standard E27 screw bulbs (easy to find)
- Glass panels rather than cheap plastic
The Bad
- IP44 waterproofing - ensure the top seal is tight
- Changing the bulb requires a screwdriver
Installer Tip:
Do not put a smart bulb (like Philips Hue) inside a PIR fixture. The sensor cuts the power, meaning the smart bulb disconnects from your Wi-Fi constantly. Use a standard 'filament style' LED bulb for a warm, vintage look that saves energy.
Priced at £15.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
Can I install an outdoor PIR sensor myself?
Why does my motion sensor light keep flashing on and off?
What is the difference between PIR and Dusk-till-Dawn sensors?
Are these lights waterproof enough for Leeds weather?
Need Professional Outdoor & Security Lighting?
Our team at OR Electrics specialises in Outdoor & Security Lighting across Leeds.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Outdoor & Security Lighting Service