Best Mains Smoke Alarms for Home Safety: 2025 Expert Review
Oli
Owner, OR Electrics & 18th Edition Electrician
If there is one device in your home you should never neglect, it's your smoke alarm. Yet, most people only think about them when they start chirping incessantly or when they're buying a house. In Leeds, with our mix of older stone properties and strict HMO licensing for student rentals, having a reliable, interlinked mains fire detection system isn't just a good idea—it is often a legal requirement.
Mains-powered alarms (Grade D1 or D2) are far superior to standard battery detectors because they are hardwired into your home's electricity supply, usually with a battery back-up. This means they are always on, and if installed correctly, they all trigger simultaneously. If a fire starts in the kitchen, the alarm in the upstairs bedroom will sound immediately.
In this review, I'm looking at three mains smoke alarms tailored to different needs: a budget-friendly option for simple updates, a high-quality twin pack for reliable coverage, and a specific single unit that solves the common headache of replacing a faulty device.
Live in Leeds?
Need your smoke alarms upgraded or certified?
Get a free quote from OR Electrics.
Specs vs. The Real World
The Spec: "10-Year Life Span"
"Manufacturers state the sensor lasts for 10 years before the unit needs replacing."
In dusty environments or homes with open fires/smoking, sensors can degrade faster. I recommend vacuuming them specifically every 6 months to ensure they reach that 10-year mark.
The Spec: "Interlinking Capability"
" alarms connect wirelessly or via wire to sound together."
You usually cannot mix brands. If you have Kidde alarms, you must buy Kidde to interlink them. Mixing brands often causes permanent fault signals.
My Top 3 Recommendations
Three options to cover different needs and budgets
Andyssey GS517A Wired Smoke Alarm Mains powered (1-PACK)
Andyssey
This Andyssey unit is a solid choice for homeowners watching their budget who still need to meet mains-powered safety standards. It features photoelectric technology, which is excellent for detecting slow-smouldering fires (like furniture burns), and includes the essential 9V battery back-up.
The Good
- Affordable entry point for mains safety
- Photoelectric sensor reduces false alarms from cooking fumes compared to ionisation
- 9V replaceable battery back-up fits standard batteries
The Bad
- Brand is less ubiquitous than Kidde or Aico, making future matching harder
- Requires hardwiring skills (not a plug-in device)
Installer Tip:
When installing these, ensure you write the installation date on the side of the unit with a permanent marker. It helps you remember when the 10-year sensor life is up, as looking for the manufacture date later involves taking the unit down.
Priced at £22.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonTwin Pack Kidde Firex KF20 Mains Powered Optical Smoke Alarm
Kidde
Kidde is one of the big names we see in consumer units and ceilings across the UK. This twin pack is fantastic value for landing and hallway coverage. Being optical alarms, they are less prone to nuisance tripping from burnt toast, making them ideal for circulation spaces near kitchens.
The Good
- Trusted trade brand known for reliability
- Optical sensor technology is clever at ignoring minor cooking fumes
- Can interlink with up to 23 other Kidde mains alarms
The Bad
- Slightly higher initial investment per unit than budget brands
- Base plates differ from older models, so may require rewiring the connector block
Installer Tip:
This twin pack is perfect for a standard standard 2-storey house. Put one continuously on the downstairs hallway ceiling and one on the upstairs landing. The interlink wire (usually a third core/wire) ensures if one detects smoke, both scream. It wakes you up faster.
Priced at £39.87 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonKidde Firex KF20 Optical Smoke Alarm (Single Unit)
Kidde
Why is a single unit a 'problem solver'? Because Kidde Firex alarms are installed in thousands of homes across Leeds. When one starts chirping due to a fault, you need an exact match to fit the existing base plate. This single KF20 is the go-to solution for replacing a failed unit without rewiring the whole system.
The Good
- Ideal for replacing a single faulty unit in an existing loop
- Standard industry fitting often allows for a simple head-unit swap
- Tamper-resistant locking prevents tenants removing the battery
The Bad
- Only compatible with the specific Kidde Firex base/connector
- Does not include heat detection (use a heat alarm for kitchens)
Installer Tip:
If you are replacing an old Kidde alarm, check the expiry date. If one has gone, the others typically aren't far behind. However, if you just need to stop a 3am chirp from a single faulty unit, this is the exact part you likely need. Turn the mains off before unclipping the old one!
Priced at £19.99 at the time of writing
Check Price on AmazonFrequently Asked Questions
Why is my mains smoke alarm beeping periodically?
Can I replace a mains smoke alarm myself?
What is the difference between Ionisation and Optical alarms?
How often should mains smoke alarms be replaced?
What happens if one alarm fails in an interlinked system?
Do landlords in Leeds need specific alarms?
Need Professional Emergency Electrical Services?
Our team at OR Electrics specialises in Emergency Electrical Services across Leeds.
Get a free quote for professional installation.
View Our Emergency Electrical Services Service